College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Recent alum torches New York 9/11 chapel

By Record Staff

Print this article

Published: Sunday, November 1, 2009

Updated: Monday, November 2, 2009

Recent Harvard Law School alumnus Brian Schroeder ’09 allegedly set fire to a chapel in Manhattan on the morning of October 31st, according to various New York media outlets, including the New York Times. The chapel, located in Memorial Park, at First Ave. and 30th St., houses the remains of unidentified victims of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center. Media that reached the scene have indicated that the remains, which are housed in a climate-controlled vault while they await DNA identification, were not affected, but that cards, flowers, and other mementoes both inside the chapel and posted to a wooden bench in the park, which was damaged, were either stolen or burned. 

Schroeder, 26, is originally from Texas. The valedictorian of his high school, he received his undergraduate degree from Duke, where he majored in theatre studies. He was co-president of HLS Lambda and served on a task force to assess how to limit the impact of military recruiting on the campus gay community. He also edited the Harvard Latino Law Review and acted in the Parody, a satirical comedy stage show about life at the school. After graduation, Schroeder moved to New York, where he had been a summer associate in 2008 for the law firm Sidley Austin. Having accepted the firm's deferral package, he was due to start as an associate there in 2011, after spending a year working at a pro bono organization with a stipend provided by the firm. Schroder was planning to use the time to work in human rights law in Switzerland. On Monday, Sidley Austin officially revoked his job offer.

He turned himself in to the police on November 1st, and his lawyer has claimed he was drugged while the incident took place, perhaps because something had slipped into his drink. There have also been allegations that the fire was set as part of a drunken dare. Still, Schroeder's motives remain unclear. He says he cannot remember what took place that night.

"Anyone who would set fire to the inviolable Memorial Park chapel is craven and contemptible," New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg said in a statement. The New York Daily News labeled him "New York's newest Public Enemy #1". Speaking to the newspaper about the incident, Sally Regenhard, whose son was a firefighter killed in the attacks, asked "why are the good people gone and the losers still with us?" The city's deputy fire chief said he didn't "know what they teach those kids at Harvard". Schroeder's mother called his actions "dumb" but said her son had committed an isolated incident that did not reflect his general character.

Schroeder was released the night of his arrest on bail. Charges for arson are currently pending.

Comments

14 comments
NY Born & Live
Fri Nov 6 2009 07:33
To HL Student: I am the "previous poster" you called out. "I am also the NY Born & Live" poster, but failed to get my name in when I responded to Sean and "In the Know". I'd like to say to you -Bravo! Your reasoning and writing are excellent. I am very impressed and encouraged.

You can guess I am considerably older than you students, and probably older than your parents. That may explain why I use multiple paragraphs when I've got something to say. I have no blog sense of what's right or wrong. You may suspect I'm somewhat of a nut...no argument here. I will tell you I've been around a bit...worked around the world with legends and geniuses (at their request) you have heard of. I've been to dinners and awards functions from the UN to Windsor Castle to Carnegie and Royal Albert Hall etc. I've been poor & rich several times each through no one's fault but my own, and/or circumstances from life itself.

This much I have learned to be an unassailable fact: jackasses come in every shape, color, size, religion, nationality, sexual preference, and socioeconomic group. Schroeder is now a guy who certainly acted like a jackass. He is paying the price. Maybe he is a wonderful guy who made a dumb mistake... as his mom said. Maybe he is a selfish, spoiled brat. I have no idea. He surely got me pissed off enough to get me typing.

My other motivation? Only this - I have great disrespect for wasted opportunities in life. HLS should house the brightest of us... who have found a way into one of this country's greatest opportunities. I don't care how spoiled or rich you may be, but I do care what you do with gifts you've been given. On the other hand, I have no respect for those who decry their lack of opportunity because they are poor, who use it as an excuse for sinking to lowlife behavior and crime.

As for my 3 sentence Switzerland rant: merely pointing out the irony of thinking the Swiss are somehow above us all in human rights. What bollocks. As for Schoeder's HLS bio paragraph? Are you kidding me? A "Task Force" discussing military recruitment of gays on Harvard's campus? I thought a task force was a group of war ships headed off to something more potentially threatening than turning down a campus recruiter... but like I admit, I'm out of the jargon loop by decades. I'm from a time when we were drafted. I turned down a West Point recruitment in the midst of Viet Nam, to find my student deferment revoked months later. Sorry, but I can't imagine why gay or straight Harvard students need a study on either volunteering (or not) for military service. Both choices seem pretty easy to act on. For me, the parody was in the article itself.

I wish you all the best in your studies and futures. I've enjoyed my nutty and multiple paragraph rant as a guest on your site. I hope there are more like HLS Student in your ranks. We expect alot from you people.

HLStudent
Thu Nov 5 2009 12:57
to the previous poster - I can't believe you call out people in this thread for discussing seemingly tangential aspects of this story relating to HLS, then spout off about how spoiled HLS students are (even digressing into a long rant about Switzerland) for paragraphs and paragraphs. clearly you're motivated less by the horror that commenters here didn't bother to parrot the obvious reaction (that burning the chapel was awful...what more is there to say, anyway?) than some burning resentment toward harvard law.
Your name
Wed Nov 4 2009 08:00
The insensitivity I cited refers to the posters who used the story as fodder for a lawyer joke, and the comment about every HLS student doing something stupid while drunk... as if Schroeder was a drunk country kid in search of cows to tip or some other childish prank. "Oh jeez... no cows in the big city...gotta blow off some steam." The discussions about some HLS parody and the political incorrectness of stereotyping don't even belong in this string. Imagine you are waiting 8 years for identification of a loved one's body parts - and you click a link to this story and find yourself scanning the comments after reading the story. Aside from Doug's comment, the lack of impassioned outrage in the other comments is Seinfeldian in it's indifference to other people's suffering.

I do find it encouraging that two comments replied to mine in defense of the possible humanity of HLS' people. But I'm not surprised both of you didn't see my point straight off. I think you are young, and have probably been in school since kindergarten. You will learn.

Read the paragraph with Schroeder's bio. Duke = $160k of college education. HLS costs? You'd know better. He was off to do "pro bono" work for "human rights" in Switzerland, with a stipend from the firm that hired him. "Stipend" is such a great word. It's always used when the money is supposedly attached to a loftier purpose than "salary". Human rights work at a law mill in Switzerland! Editing documents decrying genocide and injustice, in hopes they will eventually be presented at some useless forum like the UN! Doing this in a spotlessly clean, fabulously wealthy country whose great wealth began with exported Nazi plunder... which is the very reason they were accorded "neutral" status by Nazi Germany. Currently, Swiss bank wealth is sustained by world wide criminal need to hide and protect wealth - for arms dealers, corrupt government officials, drug lords, embezzlers, and tax cheats. But it's a great place, especially because there aren't any homeless people.

Imagine Schroeder's thoughts: "Hmmm...money....Europe...human rights credentials...European women...skiing...40 hour work week...then Manhattan...Wall Street area or Upper West Side? Oh yeah... I'll say that's pretty damned bono you betcha! Hey guys, wouldn't it really suck if we still had a draft? Then my "service" on the task force to limit "the impact of military recruiting on the campus gay community" might have been relevant. I'd would have had to find other ways to earn credits doing nothing!"

Now - please explain to me why HLS needs a separate entity for parody?

Sean
Tue Nov 3 2009 14:30
re: "in the know", I agree completely ... I guess that is the essence of the problem with HLS. Not sure how one could address it.

re: NY Born, I agree with everything you say except that part about looking down on the police or firefighters. Maybe I don't read enough HLS blogs (I only happened upon this one) but I didn't see anything here that was disrespectful or anything defending Schroeder. No doubt the world is full of snobs and pretentious law school graduates, but did someone here deserve your suggestion that we look down upon firefighters or policemen? Both of my grandfathers were policemen and one died in the line of duty, making my dad an orphan.

You have a good point about many people, but applying to the people who commented here, without knowing them or seeing any evidence of disrespect, is an excellent example of stereotyping.

in the know
Tue Nov 3 2009 12:22
to the previous commenter - where do you see "HLS blogs" being "insensitive" to the fact that the chapel contained remains? are you aware that HLS graduates also died on Sept. 11th? this school and its graduates are not exactly 100% as remote from the tragedy as Schroeder apparently was
NY Born & Live
Tue Nov 3 2009 07:24
The NYPD and FDNY who ran into the buildings didn't go to HLS. But I'll bet they ran in to try and save HLS grads with the same concerns they had for immigrant janitors. What makes this city great are the people who live and work here. Those of you who show up here with elite educational credentials in order to reap the big bucks available here wind up being taken care of by the very people you look down on. The idiot Schroeder is no big deal. The disappointment is reading HLS blogs that show no sensitivity to his attempted desecration of as yet unidentified remains. Some of those pathetic body parts are friends of mine. Some of them died trying to help HLS grads.
in the know
Mon Nov 2 2009 17:45
@Sean - maybe that's because people at HLS actually don't know each other all that well, and prefer to remain anonymous within their large classes. makes sense that they would be forced to rely on preconceptions of their fellow students. the internet has probably exacerbated this problem by allowing students to transport themselves to a world outside campus even while sitting in class. not many people are involved in or interested in campus politics the way they were in obama's time.
Sean
Mon Nov 2 2009 17:09
Thanks "in the know" ... I hadn't heard about that controversy but it reminds me (a '92 grad) what a strange place HLS is. I mean, every year in the bank where I work, the associates do some sort of parody sketch or video poking fun at various managers and colleagues, which is usually hilarious. If you actually know people well, there are so many quirks they have that you can parody in a good-natured way, why on earth do you need to rely on stereotypes to be funny?
Sean
Mon Nov 2 2009 15:34
Can someone explain the reference to the 2006 HLS parody and town hall referred to in previous comment?
Your name
Mon Nov 2 2009 11:37
If HLS took away degrees from every student or former student who embarassed himself for doing something stupid while drunk, well...I don't think there would be many HLS degrees out there.
Ogletree
Mon Nov 2 2009 01:38
Does setting fire to a memorial chapel housing 9-11 victims make you more reviled than the creators of the 2006 HLS Parody? If the town hall was any indication, the answer is: no. Not even close.
Doug
Sun Nov 1 2009 20:46
If Harvard Law had any real people in charge they would immediately revoke Brian Schroeder's degree. They do have the capability to do that.
me
Sun Nov 1 2009 20:25
Sounds like a regular lawyer to me!






log out